We seem to be at an impasse in education. It is too many cooks spoiling the broth. It is paralysis by analysis. It is every school and every teacher for himself, doing his own thing. Educators argue and argue and little seems to change. We are waiting for miracles to happen. Surely, the true formula for success will be revealed to the nation. Eventually the funds and the necessary legislation will emerge. It is only a matter of time and patience.
We wait for poverty to go away, the best teachers to arrive, the standardized testing to end, and on and on. In the meantime, students struggle to graduate and go on to college. The economy slows down, again, and we wait for some spontaneous recovery, or some messianic leadership from Washington. It is not happening.
Napolean said: From the sublime to the ridiculous is but a step. The situation in education seems so ridiculous. Perhaps we can find some steps to go backward from the ridiculous to the sublime.
A man came to the Jewish sage Shamai and asked if he could teach him the whole Torah, while he was standing on one foot. Shamai said he could not. The man then approached the sage Hillel with the same question. Hillel said: What is hateful to you, do not do to anyone else. All the rest is commentary. Go and learn it.
Perhaps we could start motivating ourselves by admitting that we are not motivated to begin with. We could imagine pleading a case in court that we were not prepared to do the right thing. Then the judge or teacher could try to explain to us how we might become motivated, next time. Thus, a critical review process could be used, with others or by ourselves, if necessary.
(Agree to disagree and compare) (THEY SAY I SAY book)
There does not seem to be any easy way to fix our failing schools, but maybe, like Hillel, we can begin with one step..
But note that psychology is MESSY and not straightforward or sure. It is about chance and statistics, like in sports. In sports, the more you practice and the better you get, the better your chances of winning. Motivation may also rise.
Also, positive FEEL GOOD reactions are not needed to learning, all the time. Students and teachers do not have to be ON EDGE, with excitement, all the time. See DULLMEN.com .
Even some unpleasant, boring times are OK and even helpful without demanding reward.
They Say / I Say 7min Video
Learned Helplessness 3min Video
RX Check list picks of Advice for each Student and Teacher?
==============================================
I Don't Want to Go to School 3min
Bored of Education 1936 10min
Outline:
Introduction to the Problem of Fixing Education
a) Key Ideas
b) My History
c) Some Exercises
d) Concluding Remarks




















